FORECASTING PANDEMIC TAX REVENUES IN A SMALL, OPEN ECONOMY: THE CASE OF BULGARIA
Abstract
Tax analysis and forecasting of revenues are of paramount importance to ensure fiscal policy’s viability and sustainability. However, the measures taken to contain the spread of the recent pandemic pose an unprecedented challenge to established models and approaches. This paper proposes a model to forecast tax revenues in Bulgaria for the fiscal years 2020–2022 built in accordance with the International Monetary Fund's recommendations on a dataset covering the period between 1995 and 2019. The study further discusses the actual trustworthiness of official Bulgarian forecasts, contrasting those figures with the model previously estimated. This study's quantitative results both confirm the pandemic's assumed negative impact on tax revenues and prove that econometrics can be tweaked to produce consistent revenue forecasts even in the relatively-unexplored case of Bulgaria offering new insights to policymakers and advocates.
Author Contributions
All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
References
1.
Alessi L, Ghysels E, Onorante L, Peach R, Potter S. Central Bank Macroeconomic Forecasting During the Global Financial Crisis: The European Central Bank and Federal Reserve Bank of New York Experiences. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics. 2014. p. 483–500.
2.
Amadeo K. When Will Interest Rates Go Up?’ The Balance. 2021.
3.
Arminger G, Clogg C, Sobel M. Handbook of Statistical Modeling for the Social and Behavioral Sciences. Springer; 1995.
4.
Barrero J, Maria N, Bloom S, Davis. COVID-19 Is Also a Reallocation Shock. National Bureau of Economic Research; 2020.
5.
ВМРО иска средна пенсия 700 лв. [IMRO wants an average pension of BGN 700. 2021.
6.
Blustein D, Duffy R, Ferreira J, Cohen-Scali V, Gali Cinamon R, Allan B. Unemployment in the Time of COVID-19: A Research Agenda. Journal of Vocational Behavior. 2020. p. 103436.
7.
Box G, Gwilym M, Jenkins G, Reinsel G, Ljung. Time Series Analysis: Forecasting and Control. 5th ed. Wiley Series in Probabilit and Statistics. John Wiley & Sons, Inc; 2016.
8.
Brinca P, Duarte J, Faria-E-Castro M. Measuring Sectoral Supply and Demand Shocks During COVID-19’. SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 3601938. Social Science Research Network. 2020.
9.
Brubakk L, Sveen T. NEMO a New Macro Model for Forecasting and Monetary Policy Analysis. Norges Bank -Economic Bulletin. 2009. p. 9.
10.
Carroll C, Kimball M. On the Concavity of the Consumption Function. Econometrica. 1996. p. 981–92.
11.
Carroll C, Slacalek J, Tokuoka K, White M. The Distribution of Wealth and the Marginal Propensity to Consume: The Distribution of Wealth. Quantitative Economics. 2017. p. 977–1020.
12.
Chakraborty S. COVID-19 and Women Informal Sector Workers in India. Economic and Political Weekly. 2020.
13.
Индексират Всички Пенсии с Между 5 и 10% От Юли Догодина [Indexing of All Pensions by between 5 and 10% from July next Year. DarikNews.Bg. 2020.
14.
Dellas H, Malliaropulos D, Papageorgiou D, Vourvachaki E. 2017.
15.
Fiscal policy with an informal sector. Bank of Greece;
16.
Demertzis M. Ανάκαμψη σχήματος Κ και δημοσιονομική πολιτική [K-shaped recovery and fiscal policy. Kathimerini. sec. Money Review; 2021.
17.
Demertzis M, Dominguez M, -Jimenez. Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs, Policy Department for Economic, Scientific and Quality of Life Policies. European Parliament; 2020.
18.
Bruegel_Final, Pdf.
19.
Demertzis M, Viegi N. Inflation Targets as Focal Points. International Journal of Central Banking. 2008. p. 55–87.
20.
Steering the boat towards an unknown destination Interview by Giuseppe Porcaro. 2020.
21.
Diacon PE, Maha LG. Consumption and GDP: A Time Series, Cross-Country Analysis’. Procedia Economics and Finance, 2nd GLOBAL CONFERENCE on BUSINESS, ECONOMICS, MANAGEMENT and TOURISM. 2015. p. 1535–43.
22.
Dickey D, Fuller W. Distribution of the Estimators for Autoregressive Time Series with a Unit Root. Journal of the American Statistical Association. 1979. p. 427–31.
23.
Likelihood Ratio Statistics for Autoregressive Time Series with a Unit Root. Econometrica. 1981. p. 1057–72.
24.
Diebold F, Mariano R. Comparing Predictive Accuracy. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics. 2002. p. 134–44.
25.
Domm P. Rising Interest Rates May Continue to Test the Stock Market in the Week Ahead. CNBC. 2021.
26.
Australia D. Government of Australia. 2008.
27.
Draganov N. Рестрикции -добре, но къде са мерките за засегнатите? [Restrictions -well, but where are the measures for those affected? Barikada. 2020.
28.
Ecb. Flat Taxes in Central and Eastern Europe’. In Monthly Bulletin. European Central Bank; 2007. p. 81–3.
29.
Eurosystem Staff Macroeconomic Projections for the Euro Area. European Central Bank; 2020.
30.
Estupinan X, Sharma M. Job and Wage Losses in Informal Sector Due to the COVID-19 Lockdown Measures in India’. SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 3680379. Social Science Research Network. 2020.
31.
European Economy Forecast 2020, Autumn. European Economic Forecast; 2020.
32.
Eurostat. NACE Rev. 2. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities. 2008.
33.
Income Inequality and Poverty Indicators’. EUROSTAT -Experimental Statistics. 2017.
34.
Impact of COVID-19 on Employment Income -Advanced Estimates’. EUROSTAT -Experimental Statistics. 2020.
35.
Structure of Household Population by Activity Status of the Reference Person’. EUROSTAT Data. 2020.
36.
COVID-19 Impact on Employment Income’. EUROSTAT -Experimental Statistics. 2020.
37.
GDP per Capita in PPS’. EUROSTAT Data. 15AD.
38.
Social Benefits (Other than Social Transfers in Kind) Paid by General Government’. EUROSTAT Data. 2021.
39.
Fisher J, David S, Johnson T, Smeeding J, Thompson. Estimating the Marginal Propensity to Consume Using the Distributions of Income, Consumption, and Wealth. Journal of Macroeconomics. 2020. p. 1–14.
40.
Frankel J. Over-Optimism in Forecasts by Official Budget Agencies and Its Implications. Oxford Review of Economic Policy. 2011. p. 536–62.
41.
Frankel J, Schreger J. Over-Optimistic Official Forecasts and Fiscal Rules in the Eurozone. Review of World Economics. 2013. p. 247–72.
42.
Gaddy C, Gale W. Demythologizing the Russian Flat Tax. Tax Notes International. 2005.
43.
Granger C. Investigating Causal Relations by Econometric Models and Cross-Spectral Methods’. Econometrica. 1969. p. 424.
44.
Guerrieri V, Lorenzoni G, Straub L, Werning I. Macroeconomic Implications of COVID-19: Can Negative Supply Shocks Cause Demand Shortages? 2020.
45.
Harvey A, Todd P. Forecasting Economic Time Series with Structural and Box-Jenkins Models: A Case Study. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics. 1983. p. 299–307.
46.
Heckelman J. Economic Freedom and Economic Growth: A Short-Run Causal Investigation. Journal of Applied Economics. 2000. p. 71–91.
47.
Hsing Y. On the Relationship between Economic Growth and Government Debt for Bulgaria. Test of the Reinhart-Rogoff Hypothesis’. Theoretical and Applied Economics. 2020. p. 187–94.
48.
Ilo. Young Workers Will Be Hit Hard by COVID-19’s Economic Fallout’. Work In Progress -International Labour Organization (blog). 2020.
49.
Imf Fad. Challenges in Forecasting Tax Revenue’. Research note. Special Series on Fiscal Policies to Respond to COVID-19. International Monetary Fund; 2020.
50.
Ivanov D. Interview by Hristo Nikolov. Bloomberg TV -Bulgaria. 2021.
51.
Karagyozova-Markova K, Deyanov G, Iliev V. Fiscal Policy and Economic Growth in Bulgaria. Discussion Papers / Bulgarian National Bank 90. 2013.
52.
Kato J. Regressive Taxation and the Welfare State: Path Dependence and Policy Diffusion. Cambridge University Press; 2003.
53.
Keen M, Michael. The Anatomy of the VAT. International Monetary Fund; 2013.
54.
Kirchgässner G, Wolters J, Hassler U. Introduction to Modern Time Series Analysis. Springer Texts in Business and Economics. Springer; 2013.
55.
Kolasa A. Life Cycle Income and Consumption Patterns in Transition’. SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 2210348. Social Science Research Network. 2012.
56.
Legeida N, Sologoub D. Institute for Economic Research and Policy Consulting. 2003.
57.
Lex. С 9% ДДС ще са ресторанти, хотели, книги, детски храни и памперси [The 9% VAT will be restaurants, hotels, books, children’s food and diapers. Lex.bg News. 2020.
58.
Mackenzie M. Should Equity Investors Worry about Rising Interest Rates? The Financial Times. 2021.
59.
Mediapool. Сивата икономика се е свила до 21%, но липсата на реформи забавя темпа [The informal economy has shrunk to 21%, but the lack of reforms is slowing down. Mediapool.bg. 2020.
60.
Milcheva E. Коронавирус: какви мерки предприема българското правителство [Coronavirus: what measures the Bulgarian government is taking. Deutsche Welle. 2020.
61.
Minfin Na R. Средносрочна б джетна прогноза за периода. Ministerstvo na Finansiite na Republika Bŭlgaria; 2016.
62.
Morozumi A, Ormaechea S. The Value Added Tax and Growth: Design Matters’. Working Paper 96. IMF Working Papers. International Monetary Fund; 2019.
63.
Narula R. Policy Opportunities and Challenges from the COVID-19 Pandemic for Economies with Large Informal Sectors. Journal of International Business Policy. 2020. p. 302–10.
64.
Nau R. Mathematical Structure of ARIMA Models. Fuqua School of Business. 2014.
65.
Nikolova G. Обмислят Две Увеличения На Пенсиите През 2021 г. [Two Pension Increases under Consideration in 2021. BTV Новините. 2020.
66.
Noi. Добавки Към Пенсии [Pension Supplements]’. Natsionalen Osiguritelen Institut. 2020.
67.
Пенсиите и Добавките От 50 Лева Към Тях Ще Се Изплащат Между 7 и 21. 2020.
68.
Декември. Pensions and Supplements of BGN 50 to Them Will Be Paid between December 7 and 21. Natsionalen Osiguritelen Institut. 30AD.
69.
Справка За Среден Основен Размер На Водещата Пенсия. Natsionalen Osiguritelen Institut. 2021.
70.
Nsi. Население и демографски процеси през 2019 година [Population and demographic processes in 2019. Natsionalen Statisticheski Institut. 2020.
71.
БВП -Производствен Метод -Национално Ниво [GDP -Production Method -National Level. Natsionanel Statisticheski Institut. 2020.
72.
Общ Доход На Домакинствата. Natsionanel. 2020.
73.
Institut S. 22AD.
74.
Ns-Rb. Закон за Българската народна банка. 2020.
75.
Tax on Personal Income’. OECD Data. OECD; 2020.
76.
Petkov V. Advantages and Disadvantages of Fiscal Discipline in Bulgaria in Times of Crisis. Contemporary Economics. 2014. p. 47–56.
77.
Rosser J, Barkley M, Rosser E, Ahmed. Income Inequality and the Informal Economy in Transition Economies. Journal of Comparative Economics. 2000. p. 156–71.
78.
Streimikiene D, Raheem Ahmed R, Vveinhardt J, Pervaiz Ghauri S, Zahid S. Forecasting Tax Revenues Using Time Series Techniquesa Case of Pakistan. Economic Research-Ekonomska Istraživanja. 2018. p. 722–54.
79.
Tamaoka M. The Regressivity of a Value Added Tax: Tax Credit Method and Subtraction Method -A Japanese Case. Fiscal Studies. 1994. p. 57–73.
80.
Telarico F, Ashtar. The US’s Schizophrenic Recovery: Banks’ Earnings on the Rise as the Government Bails out Families’. Global Risk Insights. 2021.
81.
Tiao G, Box G. Modeling Multiple Time Series with Applications. Journal of the American Statistical Association. 1981.
82.
Tosun M, Serkan S, Abizadeh. Economic Growth and Tax Components: An Analysis of Tax Changes in OECD. Applied Economics. 2005. p. 2251–63.
83.
Toteva P. Работодателите: Недекларираната заетост е най-масовата сива практика [Employers: Undeclared employment is the most common gray practice. Flashnews (blog). 2021.
84.
ВМРО Приема Индексиране На Пенсиите [IMRO Accepts Indexation of Pensions. Trud.Bg. 2020.
The statements, opinions and data contained in the journal are solely those of the individual authors and contributors and not of the publisher and the editor(s). We stay neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
